Hi Ramesh,

this issue seems to be related with removal of @DefaultMessage annotations,
moving the default (English) strings into corresponding .properties files.

As we generally want default strings to reside in .properties files, I see
following options to explore, based on our earlier conversation:

1, try annotating UIMessages interface with:
   @Generate(format = "com.google.gwt.i18n.server.PropertyCatalogFactory")

   - ref: https://github.com/gwtproject/gwt/issues/7032#issuecomment-110858030
   - this is likely non-feasible, however, since @Generate requests generation
     of translation sources (.properties) from Java code

2, try removing @AlternateMessage annotation and modify .properties file:
   recurrenceType=Incorrect enum
   recurrenceType[UNKNOWN]=None
   recurrenceType[INTERVAL]=Minute
   recurrenceType[HOURLY]=Hourly
   recurrenceType[DAILY]=Daily
   recurrenceType[WEEKLY]=Weekly
   recurrenceType[MONTHLY]=Monthly

   - ref: http://www.gwtproject.org/doc/latest/DevGuideI18nPluralForms.html
   - this might not work as it might be @PluralCount-only (not for @Select)

3, remove @AlternateMessage & handle enum-to-string formatting on our own

   String sizeUnitString(String size, @Messages.Select SizeConverter.SizeUnit sizeUnit);
   becomes
   String sizeUnitString(String size, String sizeUnitValue);

   String recurrenceType(@Select GlusterVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence recurrence);
   gets removed, because there is no point in having "{0}" message

   getMessages().sizeUnitString(size, sizeUnit);
   becomes
   getMessages().sizeUnitString(size, <someUtility>(sizeUnit));

   getMessages().recurrenceType(recurrence);
   becomes
   <someUtility>(recurrence);

Personally, I think 3, is the most correct solution. As Alex wrote below,
we're planning to switch away from GWT i18n mechanism in the long-term;
relying on @AlternateMessage etc. is therefore an obstacle to that effort.

Also, we already have infra for localizing enum members: LocalizedEnums

So as part of solution 3, we should add into LocalizedEnums:

  String GlusterVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence___INTERVAL();
  String GlusterVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence___HOURLY();
  String GlusterVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence___DAILY();
  String GlusterVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence___WEEKLY();
  String GlusterVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence___MONTHLY();
  String GlusterVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence___UNKNOWN();

plus add corresponding strings in LocalizedEnums.properties file.

This way, we can leverage existing EnumTranslator#translate method.

By doing so, <someUtility> mentioned above === EnumTranslator#translate

Regards,
Vojtech

----- Original Message -----
> From: "Alexander Wels" <awels@redhat.com>
> To: "Ramesh Nachimuthu" <rnachimu@redhat.com>
> Cc: "devel" <devel@ovirt.org>, "Vojtech Szocs" <vszocs@redhat.com>, "Scott Dickerson" <sdickers@redhat.com>
> Sent: Thursday, July 28, 2016 2:21:23 PM
> Subject: Re: Strange issues with com.google.gwt.i18n.client.Messages.AlternateMessage [bz#1358837]
>
> On Thursday, July 28, 2016 05:49:57 AM Ramesh Nachimuthu wrote:
> > Hi,
> >
> >  We have a strange issue with the
> > com.google.gwt.i18n.client.Messages.AlternateMessage in UIMessages.java. We
> > have defined some alternate messages using @Messages.Select with Enums. But
> > its doesn't work any more.
> >
> > We have following messages in the UIMessages.java.
> >
> >     @Messages.AlternateMessage(value = { "UNKNOWN" , "None" , "INTERVAL" ,
> > "Minute" , "HOURLY" , "Hourly" , "DAILY" , "Daily" , "WEEKLY" , "Weekly" ,
> > "MONTHLY" , "Monthly" }) String recurrenceType(@Messages.Select
> >     GlusterVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence recurrence);
> >
> >     @Messages.AlternateMessage(value = { "BYTES" , "{0} B" , "KiB" , "{0}
> > KiB" , "MiB" , "{0} MiB" , "GiB" , "{0} GiB" , "TiB" , "{0} TiB" }) String
> > sizeUnitString(String size, @Messages.Select
> >     SizeConverter.SizeUnit sizeUnit);
> >
> > But the generated UIMessages_.java doesn't use any of the enum conditions.
> >
> >   public java.lang.String
> > recurrenceType(org.ovirt.engine.core.common.businessentities.gluster.Gluste
> > rVolumeSnapshotScheduleRecurrence arg0) { java.lang.String returnVal =
> > null;
> >     int arg0_ordinal = -1;
> >     if (arg0 != null) {
> >       arg0_ordinal = arg0.ordinal();
> >     }
> >     if (returnVal != null) {
> >       return returnVal;
> >     }
> >     return "Incorrect enum";
> >   }
> >
> >   public java.lang.String sizeUnitString(java.lang.String
> > arg0,org.ovirt.engine.core.common.utils.SizeConverter.SizeUnit arg1) {
> > java.lang.String returnVal = null;
> >     int arg1_ordinal = -1;
> >     if (arg1 != null) {
> >       arg1_ordinal = arg1.ordinal();
> >     }
> >     if (returnVal != null) {
> >       return returnVal;
> >     }
> >     return arg0 + " TiB";
> >   }
> >
> > It used to work earlier. Is there any known issue in the current GWT
> > Version? or Am I missing something?.
> >
> > Regards,
> > Ramesh
>
> We have an active project to remove all the annotations from the Messages
> interfaces in the project. I am guessing that is probably the cause of your
> problems. I am fairly certain there is an alternative to the annotations now,
> but I don't know of the top of my head. Scott can you give them the details?
>
> Alexander
>
>