Hi,
I don't do top-postings, just a reply to all.
It works now on all hosts!
I was testing with a Run Once with no macspoof option and changed the CARP IP on the pfsense box to alias, and back to carp... where with alias I was able to ping with carp not... and this was good because of the disabled macspoof option. After this change I was also, with spoof true and not set, able to ping the IP on the CARP interface itself, so I think Pfsense messed something up here with ARP tables (I know form the past).
After a restart of the VM I was able to ping all IP, also CARP as it was starting with macspoof true again.
Some other thing I'm curious about... let's say you have 3 servers in a cluster, 2 installed with the macspoof hook and one not. The VM with macspoof enabled starts on the host without the hook and you migrate it to a host where the hooks is installed. What happens... ?
Cheers,
Matt