[Users] Free IPA + oVirt setup fails

[i iordanov]

Hey,

I actually realized that something I wrote is inaccurate.

UserB, who was not granted permission to any VM was actually able to
connect to a freshly booted UserA's VM. Subsequently, UserA was unable to
connect to "his own VM" anymore, and the error message was:

Operation Failed: [user cannot force reconnect to vm]

When UserB then shut down UserA's VM, UserA was able to power it on and
attach to it. Subsequently, UserB was not able to connect to the VM again
with the same message UserA was getting (user cannot force connect to vm).

What I expected is that UserB would not see, not be able to power control,
and not be able to attach at all to UserA's VM, so this behavior is quite
puzzling to me!

Any clarification and help would be appreciated!

Thanks,
iordan



On Sat, Nov 23, 2013 at 7:50 PM, i iordanov <iiordanov at gmail.com> wrote:

> Hi Juan,
>
> On Sat, Nov 23, 2013 at 3:03 PM, Juan Hernandez <jhernand at redhat.com>wrote:
>
>> Did you change it while the server was running? If so during stop the
>> server will probably overwrite the file. Try to change it after stopping
>> the server:
>>
>
> Yes, it was absolutely because the server was running and was writing out
> its configuration upon being stopped.
>
> In fact modifying the file is not good practice, you may prefer to do it
>> using LDAP:
>>
>
> I guess this method would not have suffered from the clobbered config file
> :D. Thanks for the additional tip, I'm quite new to LDAP.
>
>
>> I have just tested this in my local environment and with minssf=1 it
>> works correctly, including the ability to search for users in the LDAP
>> directory from the administration GUI and using those users to log in to
>> both the administration GUI and to the user portal.
>>
>
> I can definitely now confirm that changing minssf to 1 worked around the
> issue.
>
> However, I'm faced with either an issue or a misunderstanding of how
> things work in oVirt. I was able to add a couple of users to IPA (user A
> and user B) and then import them with UserRole into oVirt. What is puzzling
> is that both are able to see(!!) and power on/off(!!!!!) all the machines
> which were created by and for user admin at internal. Some of these machines
> are based on the Blank template and some on a different template (if that
> matters). Thankfully, at least the new users are unable to attach to the
> console of those machines.
>
> When I created a new virtual machine and in the permissions added user A
> as UserRole, user A now has access to the console of that VM. However, what
> was again puzzling is that user B can see and power on/off the new virtual
> machine, but at least cannot attach to the console (consistent with my
> previous findings).
>
> I would have thought that users would "see" and be able to power on/off
> only their own VMs, and something tells me that this is the way it was
> intended. So what do you think is broken in my test rig?
>
> Thank you very much!
> iordan
>
> --
> The conscious mind has only one thread of execution.
>



-- 
The conscious mind has only one thread of execution.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.ovirt.org/pipermail/users/attachments/20131123/99523a82/attachment.html>