After looking at this, I hit upon something.
Each machine in this cluster has two drives -- a 500gb and a 1 tb one. Each machine I was
installing to the 500gb drive (going to put in bigger drives, but this was what was laying
around)
I went through and looked at the machines, and the one that was failing had the 500gb
drive as the second drive. Reversed them, wiped everything and reloaded. Seems to be
installing now.