6 p.m.
I am testing the migration from CentOS7/oVirt 4.3 to CentOS8/oVirt 4.4.
Exporting all VMs to OVAs, and re-importing them on a new cluster built from scratch seems
the safest and best method, because in the step-by-step migration, there is simply far too
many things that can go wrong and no easy way to fail-back after each step.
But of course it requires that one of the most essential operations in a hypervisor
actualy works.
For me a hypervisor turns a machine into a file and a file into a machine: That's the
most appreciated and fundamental quality of it.
oVirt fails right there, repeatedly, and for different reasons and without even reporting
an error.
So I have manually put the single-line fix in, which settles udev to ensure that disks are
not exported as zeros. That's the bug which renders the final release oVirt 4.3
forever unfit, 4 years before the end of maintenance of CentOS7, because it won't be
fixed there.
Exporting VMs and re-importing them on another farm generally seemed to work after that.
But just as I was exporting not one of the trivial machines, that I have been using for
testing, but one of the bigger ones, that actually contain a significant amout of data, I
find myself hitting this timeout bug.
The disks for both the trival and less-trivial are defined at 500GB, thinly allocated. The
trivial is the naked OS at something like 7GB actually allocated, the 'real' has
113GB allocated. In both cases the OVA export file to a local SSD xfs partition is 500GB,
with lots of zeros and sparse allocation in the case of the first one.
The second came to 72GB of 500GB actually allocated, which didn't seem like a good
sign already, but perhaps there was some compression involved?
Still the export finished without error or incident and the import on the other side went
just as well. The machine even boots and runs, it was only once I started using it, that I
suddenly had all types of file system errors... it turns out 113-73GB were actually really
cut off and missing from the OVA export, and there is nobody and nothing checking for
that.
I now know that qemu-img is used in the process, which actually runs in a pipe. There is
no checksumming or any other logic involved to ensure that the format conversion of the
disk image has retained the integrity of the image. There is no obvious simple solution
that I can think of, but the combination of processing the image through a pipe and an
impatient ansible timeout results in a hypervisor which fails on the most important
elementary task: Turn a machine into a file and back into a machine.
IMHO it makes oVirt a toy, not a tool. And worst of all, I am pretty sure that RHV has the
same quality, even if the sticker price is probably quite different.
I have the export domain backup running right now, but I'm not sure it's not using
the same mechanism under the cover with potentially similar results.
Yes, I know there is a Python script that will do the backup, and probably with full
fidelity. And perhaps with this new infrastructure as code approach, that is how it should
be done anyway.
But if you have a GUI, that should just work: No excuses.
P.S. The allocation size of the big VM in the export domain is again 72GB, with the file
size at 500GB. I'll run the import on the other end, but by now I am pretty sure, the
result will be no different.
Unless you resort to Python or some external tool, there is no reliable way to back up and
restore a VM of less than 80 seconds worth of data transfer and no warning, when
corruption occurs.
I am not sure you can compete with Nutanix and VMware at this level of reliability.
P.P.S. So just where (and on which machine) do I need to change the timeout?