7:53 p.m.
Hi,
As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki that's
out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
true - it's the nature of Wikis.
When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
current information is.
I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
(sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
following links (in order shown):
http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
...
I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
about the 2nd page.
Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
Easy to do?
-Bob
10:28 p.m.
------=_Part_27076891_903352903.1394738935622
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
----- Original Message -----
From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
To: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 6:53:13 PM
Subject: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
Hi,
As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki that's
out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
true - it's the nature of Wikis.
When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
current information is.
I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
(sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
following links (in order shown):
http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
...
I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
about the 2nd page.
Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
Easy to do?
-Bob
Hi Bob,
I'm not against it and I'm aware of the fact that pages tend to become out of
date.
Since every page has a history as you can see in the attached, adding another date
seems needles.
What do you think?
Doron
------=_Part_27076891_903352903.1394738935622
Content-Type: image/png; name=dates.png
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=dates.png
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64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------=_Part_27076891_903352903.1394738935622--
11:17 p.m.
On 03/13/2014 03:28 PM, Doron Fediuck wrote:
----- Original Message -----
> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
> To: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 6:53:13 PM
> Subject: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>
> Hi,
>
> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki that's
> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>
> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
> current information is.
>
> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>
> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
> following links (in order shown):
>
> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
> ...
>
> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
> about the 2nd page.
>
> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>
> Easy to do?
>
> -Bob
>
Hi Bob,
I'm not against it and I'm aware of the fact that pages tend to become out of
date.
Since every page has a history as you can see in the attached, adding another date
seems needles.
What do you think?
Hi Doron,
I was thinking of something very simple - a clear text date on ever page
on the Wiki.
I can't see anything that looks like your attached picture of menus on
this page, for example:
http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
Do you have to log in to see that menu? If so, that's not very helpful
to those without accounts...
-Bob
6:16 a.m.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
To: "Doron Fediuck" <dfediuck(a)redhat.com>
Cc: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 10:17:22 PM
Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
On 03/13/2014 03:28 PM, Doron Fediuck wrote:
>
> ----- Original Message -----
>> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
>> To: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
>> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 6:53:13 PM
>> Subject: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>>
>> Hi,
>>
>> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki
that's
>> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
>> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>>
>> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
>> current information is.
>>
>> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
>> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
>> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
>> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
>> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
>> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
>> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>>
>> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
>> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
>> following links (in order shown):
>>
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
>> ...
>>
>> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
>> about the 2nd page.
>>
>> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
>> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
>> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
>> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>>
>> Easy to do?
>>
>> -Bob
>>
> Hi Bob,
> I'm not against it and I'm aware of the fact that pages tend to become out
> of date.
> Since every page has a history as you can see in the attached, adding
> another date
> seems needles.
>
> What do you think?
Hi Doron,
I was thinking of something very simple - a clear text date on ever page
on the Wiki.
I can't see anything that looks like your attached picture of menus on
this page, for example:
http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
Do you have to log in to see that menu? If so, that's not very helpful
to those without accounts...
-Bob
Hi Bob,
so for that we have the update date:
Current status
Initial POC devel
Last updated: March 13, 2014
11:15 a.m.
Il 14/03/2014 04:16, Doron Fediuck ha scritto:
----- Original Message -----
> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
> To: "Doron Fediuck" <dfediuck(a)redhat.com>
> Cc: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 10:17:22 PM
> Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>
>
> On 03/13/2014 03:28 PM, Doron Fediuck wrote:
>>
>> ----- Original Message -----
>>> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
>>> To: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
>>> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 6:53:13 PM
>>> Subject: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>>>
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki
that's
>>> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
>>> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>>>
>>> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
>>> current information is.
>>>
>>> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
>>> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
>>> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
>>> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
>>> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
>>> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
>>> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>>>
>>> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
>>> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
>>> following links (in order shown):
>>>
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
>>> ...
>>>
>>> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to
tell
>>> about the 2nd page.
>>>
>>> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
>>> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
>>> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
>>> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>>>
>>> Easy to do?
>>>
>>> -Bob
>>>
>> Hi Bob,
>> I'm not against it and I'm aware of the fact that pages tend to become
out
>> of date.
>> Since every page has a history as you can see in the attached, adding
>> another date
>> seems needles.
>>
>> What do you think?
> Hi Doron,
>
> I was thinking of something very simple - a clear text date on ever page
> on the Wiki.
>
> I can't see anything that looks like your attached picture of menus on
> this page, for example:
> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>
> Do you have to log in to see that menu? If so, that's not very helpful
> to those without accounts...
>
> -Bob
>
Hi Bob,
so for that we have the update date:
Current status
Initial POC devel
Last updated: March 13, 2014
There is an ongoing discussion about adding correct edit dates to all wiki pages
http://lists.ovirt.org/pipermail/infra/2014-February/005448.html
The above timestamp is not right. Last change was done on November 2013‎
Fixed wiki for displaying last revision correctly as didi suggested.
We're waiting on someone with enough rights for updating all wiki pages possibly in
automated manner adding the correct line there.
Otherwise we've to go over all pages and do that manually.
_______________________________________________
Users mailing list
Users(a)ovirt.org
http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
--
Sandro Bonazzola
Better technology. Faster innovation. Powered by community collaboration.
See how it works at redhat.com
11:37 a.m.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Sandro Bonazzola" <sbonazzo(a)redhat.com>
To: "Doron Fediuck" <dfediuck(a)redhat.com>, "Bob Doolittle"
<bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
Cc: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>, "Yedidyah Bar David"
<didi(a)redhat.com>
Sent: Friday, March 14, 2014 10:15:04 AM
Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
Il 14/03/2014 04:16, Doron Fediuck ha scritto:
>
>
> ----- Original Message -----
>> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
>> To: "Doron Fediuck" <dfediuck(a)redhat.com>
>> Cc: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
>> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 10:17:22 PM
>> Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>>
>>
>> On 03/13/2014 03:28 PM, Doron Fediuck wrote:
>>>
>>> ----- Original Message -----
>>>> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
>>>> To: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
>>>> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 6:53:13 PM
>>>> Subject: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>>>>
>>>> Hi,
>>>>
>>>> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki
that's
>>>> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
>>>> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>>>>
>>>> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
>>>> current information is.
>>>>
>>>> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
>>>> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
>>>> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
>>>> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
>>>> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
>>>> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version
it's
>>>> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>>>>
>>>> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
>>>> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
>>>> following links (in order shown):
>>>>
>>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
>>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
>>>> ...
>>>>
>>>> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard
to tell
>>>> about the 2nd page.
>>>>
>>>> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly
indicate
>>>> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
>>>> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
>>>> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>>>>
>>>> Easy to do?
>>>>
>>>> -Bob
>>>>
>>> Hi Bob,
>>> I'm not against it and I'm aware of the fact that pages tend to
become
>>> out
>>> of date.
>>> Since every page has a history as you can see in the attached, adding
>>> another date
>>> seems needles.
>>>
>>> What do you think?
>> Hi Doron,
>>
>> I was thinking of something very simple - a clear text date on ever page
>> on the Wiki.
>>
>> I can't see anything that looks like your attached picture of menus on
>> this page, for example:
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>>
>> Do you have to log in to see that menu? If so, that's not very helpful
>> to those without accounts...
>>
>> -Bob
>>
>
> Hi Bob,
> so for that we have the update date:
>
> Current status
> Initial POC devel
> Last updated: March 13, 2014
There is an ongoing discussion about adding correct edit dates to all wiki
pages
http://lists.ovirt.org/pipermail/infra/2014-February/005448.html
Indeed. Last post in that thread [1] is from 3 weeks ago. Any news about that?
[1] http://lists.ovirt.org/pipermail/infra/2014-February/005502.html
Best,
--
Didi
11:35 a.m.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
To: "Doron Fediuck" <dfediuck(a)redhat.com>
Cc: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 10:17:22 PM
Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
On 03/13/2014 03:28 PM, Doron Fediuck wrote:
>
> ----- Original Message -----
>> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
>> To: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
>> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 6:53:13 PM
>> Subject: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>>
>> Hi,
>>
>> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki
that's
>> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
>> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>>
>> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
>> current information is.
>>
>> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
>> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
>> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
>> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
>> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
>> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
>> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>>
>> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
>> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
>> following links (in order shown):
>>
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
>> ...
>>
>> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
>> about the 2nd page.
>>
>> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
>> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
>> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
>> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>>
>> Easy to do?
>>
>> -Bob
>>
> Hi Bob,
> I'm not against it and I'm aware of the fact that pages tend to become out
> of date.
> Since every page has a history as you can see in the attached, adding
> another date
> seems needles.
>
> What do you think?
Hi Doron,
I was thinking of something very simple - a clear text date on ever page
on the Wiki.
I can't see anything that looks like your attached picture of menus on
this page, for example:
http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
Do you have to log in to see that menu? If so, that's not very helpful
to those without accounts...
1. So create an account, it's free :-)
2. It's indeed *shown* only to logged in users, but the links are accessible
to everyone. You can "guess" them by looking at any other mediawiki site.
E.g. for this page, the history one is:
http://www.ovirt.org/index.php?title=Features/Self_Hosted_Engine&acti...
(You'll still need to be logged in in order to edit a page).
Not sure why this is so - probably the default of the theme used there or
something like that.
--
Didi
12:07 a.m.
On 03/16/2014 04:35 AM, Yedidyah Bar David wrote:
----- Original Message -----
> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
> To: "Doron Fediuck" <dfediuck(a)redhat.com>
> Cc: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 10:17:22 PM
> Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>
>
> On 03/13/2014 03:28 PM, Doron Fediuck wrote:
>> ----- Original Message -----
>>> From: "Bob Doolittle" <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>
>>> To: "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
>>> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2014 6:53:13 PM
>>> Subject: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>>>
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki
that's
>>> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
>>> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>>>
>>> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
>>> current information is.
>>>
>>> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
>>> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
>>> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
>>> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
>>> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
>>> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
>>> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>>>
>>> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
>>> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
>>> following links (in order shown):
>>>
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
>>> ...
>>>
>>> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to
tell
>>> about the 2nd page.
>>>
>>> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
>>> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
>>> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
>>> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>>>
>>> Easy to do?
>>>
>>> -Bob
>>>
>> Hi Bob,
>> I'm not against it and I'm aware of the fact that pages tend to become
out
>> of date.
>> Since every page has a history as you can see in the attached, adding
>> another date
>> seems needles.
>>
>> What do you think?
> Hi Doron,
>
> I was thinking of something very simple - a clear text date on ever page
> on the Wiki.
>
> I can't see anything that looks like your attached picture of menus on
> this page, for example:
> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>
> Do you have to log in to see that menu? If so, that's not very helpful
> to those without accounts...
1. So create an account, it's free :-)
2. It's indeed *shown* only to logged in users, but the links are accessible
to everyone. You can "guess" them by looking at any other mediawiki site.
E.g. for this page, the history one is:
http://www.ovirt.org/index.php?title=Features/Self_Hosted_Engine&acti...
I trust we can both agree we could do better, without too much trouble.
We want to make our Wiki pages as easy to use and as helpful as possible
to everyone, not just people with accounts who have logged in before
searching for information, or who know how to do magical transformations
on Wiki URLs to determine the date ;)
I'm not trying to be critical of where we are now - just trying to
establish a baseline of what we should hope to achieve.
Regards,
Bob
8:16 p.m.
Hi Bob,
What I'd love to see is a way for people to flag content out-of-date.
"Last updated" doesn't tell you about the feature that is stable and
unchanged since 3.0, nor does it tell you that the feature is in
constant flux and the latest commit just changed everything.
You need 2 dates for maximum usefulness: "Last updated", and "Flagged
out of date" - if last updated is after the flagged date, something is
wrong (flag should have been removed). If the flag is there then the
page needs updating. Ideally, flagging the page would indicate the
reason for the flag.
Anyone know how you'd do this in a maintainable way in MediaWiki?
Cheers,
Dave.
On 03/13/2014 05:53 PM, Bob Doolittle wrote:
Hi,
As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki that's
out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
true - it's the nature of Wikis.
When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
current information is.
I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
(sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
following links (in order shown):
http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
...
I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
about the 2nd page.
Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
Easy to do?
-Bob
_______________________________________________
Users mailing list
Users(a)ovirt.org
http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
--
Dave Neary, Lyon, France
Email: dneary(a)gnome.org / Jabber: nearyd(a)gmail.com
Ph: +33 950 71 55 62 / Cell: +33 6 77 01 92 13
8:27 p.m.
The problem with (the obvious implementation of) a flag like that is you
have to trust everybody in order to believe it.
Let's face it, we've all been newbs at one time or another. Operator
error happens all the time. If just anybody can flag a page as "out of
date" (and if it only takes one vote), is the flag actually useful?
Probably not.
Seems like a good candidate for crowd sourcing. What if we could vote
(up or down) on the usefulness of a page? What if old votes timed out so
you always saw a reasonably current indication (I suppose a vote of 0
might also indicate a page nobody visits any more). This would flag
pages that need work, and also pages that are very helpful so need
vigilance to keep them so. A place for talking about the page would also
be useful (may be already there, I don't think I ever had a login for
the Wiki).
Sounds hard to do, but one can dream. Maybe somebody has a clever idea
of how to do this.
A date should be pretty easy, though ;)
-Bob
On 03/14/2014 01:16 PM, Dave Neary wrote:
Hi Bob,
What I'd love to see is a way for people to flag content out-of-date.
"Last updated" doesn't tell you about the feature that is stable and
unchanged since 3.0, nor does it tell you that the feature is in
constant flux and the latest commit just changed everything.
You need 2 dates for maximum usefulness: "Last updated", and "Flagged
out of date" - if last updated is after the flagged date, something is
wrong (flag should have been removed). If the flag is there then the
page needs updating. Ideally, flagging the page would indicate the
reason for the flag.
Anyone know how you'd do this in a maintainable way in MediaWiki?
Cheers,
Dave.
On 03/13/2014 05:53 PM, Bob Doolittle wrote:
> Hi,
>
> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki that's
> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>
> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
> current information is.
>
> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>
> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
> following links (in order shown):
>
> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
> ...
>
> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
> about the 2nd page.
>
> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>
> Easy to do?
>
> -Bob
>
> _______________________________________________
> Users mailing list
> Users(a)ovirt.org
> http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
3:03 p.m.
Il 14/03/2014 18:16, Dave Neary ha scritto:
Hi Bob,
What I'd love to see is a way for people to flag content out-of-date.
"Last updated" doesn't tell you about the feature that is stable and
unchanged since 3.0, nor does it tell you that the feature is in
constant flux and the latest commit just changed everything.
You need 2 dates for maximum usefulness: "Last updated", and "Flagged
out of date" - if last updated is after the flagged date, something is
wrong (flag should have been removed). If the flag is there then the
page needs updating. Ideally, flagging the page would indicate the
reason for the flag.
Anyone know how you'd do this in a maintainable way in MediaWiki?
Looking at mediawiki the only way I see is flagging all pages not updated in the last
month with
http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Template:Outdated
And having people to review them.
I'm not sure if a bot can do the work of automatically flagging all pages not
updated.
Cheers,
Dave.
On 03/13/2014 05:53 PM, Bob Doolittle wrote:
> Hi,
>
> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki that's
> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>
> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
> current information is.
>
> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>
> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
> following links (in order shown):
>
> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
> ...
>
> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
> about the 2nd page.
>
> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>
> Easy to do?
>
> -Bob
>
> _______________________________________________
> Users mailing list
> Users(a)ovirt.org
> http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
--
Sandro Bonazzola
Better technology. Faster innovation. Powered by community collaboration.
See how it works at redhat.com
3:15 p.m.
I would have no issue manually doing this, but the problem is as soon as I do, every page
will automatically be updated to today's date with my name as soon as I hit
"Save." So a bot might be good. Or a template change.
BKP
----- Original Message -----
From: "Sandro Bonazzola" <sbonazzo(a)redhat.com>
To: "Dave Neary" <nearyd(a)gmail.com>, "Bob Doolittle"
<bob(a)doolittle.us.com>, "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
Sent: Monday, March 17, 2014 8:03:23 AM
Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
Il 14/03/2014 18:16, Dave Neary ha scritto:
> Hi Bob,
>
> What I'd love to see is a way for people to flag content out-of-date.
> "Last updated" doesn't tell you about the feature that is stable and
> unchanged since 3.0, nor does it tell you that the feature is in
> constant flux and the latest commit just changed everything.
>
> You need 2 dates for maximum usefulness: "Last updated", and
"Flagged
> out of date" - if last updated is after the flagged date, something is
> wrong (flag should have been removed). If the flag is there then the
> page needs updating. Ideally, flagging the page would indicate the
> reason for the flag.
>
> Anyone know how you'd do this in a maintainable way in MediaWiki?
Looking at mediawiki the only way I see is flagging all pages not updated in
the last month with
http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Template:Outdated
And having people to review them.
I'm not sure if a bot can do the work of automatically flagging all pages not
updated.
>
> Cheers,
> Dave.
>
> On 03/13/2014 05:53 PM, Bob Doolittle wrote:
>> Hi,
>>
>> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki
that's
>> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
>> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>>
>> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
>> current information is.
>>
>> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
>> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
>> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
>> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
>> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
>> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
>> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>>
>> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
>> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
>> following links (in order shown):
>>
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
>> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
>> ...
>>
>> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to tell
>> about the 2nd page.
>>
>> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
>> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
>> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
>> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>>
>> Easy to do?
>>
>> -Bob
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Users mailing list
>> Users(a)ovirt.org
>> http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
>
--
Sandro Bonazzola
Better technology. Faster innovation. Powered by community collaboration.
See how it works at redhat.com
_______________________________________________
Users mailing list
Users(a)ovirt.org
http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
3:26 p.m.
Il 17/03/2014 13:15, Brian Proffitt ha scritto:
I would have no issue manually doing this, but the problem is as soon
as I do, every page will automatically be updated to today's date with my name as soon
as I hit "Save." So a bot might be good. Or a template change.
I guess we can just go over http://www.ovirt.org/Special:AncientPages, contact owner /
writer of the page / feature and ask him / her to update to
current status.
BKP
----- Original Message -----
> From: "Sandro Bonazzola" <sbonazzo(a)redhat.com>
> To: "Dave Neary" <nearyd(a)gmail.com>, "Bob Doolittle"
<bob(a)doolittle.us.com>, "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
> Sent: Monday, March 17, 2014 8:03:23 AM
> Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>
> Il 14/03/2014 18:16, Dave Neary ha scritto:
>> Hi Bob,
>>
>> What I'd love to see is a way for people to flag content out-of-date.
>> "Last updated" doesn't tell you about the feature that is stable
and
>> unchanged since 3.0, nor does it tell you that the feature is in
>> constant flux and the latest commit just changed everything.
>>
>> You need 2 dates for maximum usefulness: "Last updated", and
"Flagged
>> out of date" - if last updated is after the flagged date, something is
>> wrong (flag should have been removed). If the flag is there then the
>> page needs updating. Ideally, flagging the page would indicate the
>> reason for the flag.
>>
>> Anyone know how you'd do this in a maintainable way in MediaWiki?
>
> Looking at mediawiki the only way I see is flagging all pages not updated in
> the last month with
>
> http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Template:Outdated
>
> And having people to review them.
> I'm not sure if a bot can do the work of automatically flagging all pages not
> updated.
>
>
>
>>
>> Cheers,
>> Dave.
>>
>> On 03/13/2014 05:53 PM, Bob Doolittle wrote:
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki
that's
>>> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
>>> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>>>
>>> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
>>> current information is.
>>>
>>> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
>>> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
>>> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
>>> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
>>> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
>>> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version it's
>>> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>>>
>>> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
>>> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
>>> following links (in order shown):
>>>
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
>>> ...
>>>
>>> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard to
tell
>>> about the 2nd page.
>>>
>>> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly indicate
>>> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
>>> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
>>> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>>>
>>> Easy to do?
>>>
>>> -Bob
>>>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Users mailing list
>>> Users(a)ovirt.org
>>> http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
>>
>
>
> --
> Sandro Bonazzola
> Better technology. Faster innovation. Powered by community collaboration.
> See how it works at redhat.com
> _______________________________________________
> Users mailing list
> Users(a)ovirt.org
> http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
>
--
Sandro Bonazzola
Better technology. Faster innovation. Powered by community collaboration.
See how it works at redhat.com
5:47 p.m.
FYI, I am in discussion with the sysadmin for OSAS to build a script to perhaps stick a
universal "Lastupdated..." field on every page, down by the footer.
That should do it.
BKP
----- Original Message -----
From: "Sandro Bonazzola" <sbonazzo(a)redhat.com>
To: "Brian Proffitt" <bproffit(a)redhat.com>
Cc: "Dave Neary" <nearyd(a)gmail.com>, "Bob Doolittle"
<bob(a)doolittle.us.com>, "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
Sent: Monday, March 17, 2014 8:26:19 AM
Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
Il 17/03/2014 13:15, Brian Proffitt ha scritto:
> I would have no issue manually doing this, but the problem is as soon as I
> do, every page will automatically be updated to today's date with my name
> as soon as I hit "Save." So a bot might be good. Or a template change.
>
I guess we can just go over http://www.ovirt.org/Special:AncientPages,
contact owner / writer of the page / feature and ask him / her to update to
current status.
> BKP
>
>
> ----- Original Message -----
>> From: "Sandro Bonazzola" <sbonazzo(a)redhat.com>
>> To: "Dave Neary" <nearyd(a)gmail.com>, "Bob Doolittle"
>> <bob(a)doolittle.us.com>, "users" <users(a)ovirt.org>
>> Sent: Monday, March 17, 2014 8:03:23 AM
>> Subject: Re: [Users] Request for Wiki - dates
>>
>> Il 14/03/2014 18:16, Dave Neary ha scritto:
>>> Hi Bob,
>>>
>>> What I'd love to see is a way for people to flag content out-of-date.
>>> "Last updated" doesn't tell you about the feature that is
stable and
>>> unchanged since 3.0, nor does it tell you that the feature is in
>>> constant flux and the latest commit just changed everything.
>>>
>>> You need 2 dates for maximum usefulness: "Last updated", and
"Flagged
>>> out of date" - if last updated is after the flagged date, something is
>>> wrong (flag should have been removed). If the flag is there then the
>>> page needs updating. Ideally, flagging the page would indicate the
>>> reason for the flag.
>>>
>>> Anyone know how you'd do this in a maintainable way in MediaWiki?
>>
>> Looking at mediawiki the only way I see is flagging all pages not updated
>> in
>> the last month with
>>
>> http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Template:Outdated
>>
>> And having people to review them.
>> I'm not sure if a bot can do the work of automatically flagging all pages
>> not
>> updated.
>>
>>
>>
>>>
>>> Cheers,
>>> Dave.
>>>
>>> On 03/13/2014 05:53 PM, Bob Doolittle wrote:
>>>> Hi,
>>>>
>>>> As most are aware, there's a lot of information on the Ovirt Wiki
that's
>>>> out of date. In spite of our best efforts, that will probably always be
>>>> true - it's the nature of Wikis.
>>>>
>>>> When I look for information on our Wiki, I never know where the most
>>>> current information is.
>>>>
>>>> I think it would be really helpful if someplace on each Wiki page was a
>>>> useful date to let us know the currency of the info. Probably the most
>>>> useful date is last-modified, although creation date might also be
>>>> useful. Maybe we could even map/display the date to the version number
>>>> of whatever the current stable release was at the time for context
>>>> (sometimes the content of a page calls out a particular version
it's
>>>> addressing, but a lot of the time it does not).
>>>>
>>>> Just as an example, I want to find out about migrating my existing
>>>> configuration to self-hosted, using 3.4 RC2. A google search shows the
>>>> following links (in order shown):
>>>>
>>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Features/Self_Hosted_Engine
>>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Migrate_to_Hosted_Engine
>>>> http://www.ovirt.org/Hosted_Engine_Howto
>>>> ...
>>>>
>>>> I'm sure the Features page is ancient at this point. It's hard
to tell
>>>> about the 2nd page.
>>>>
>>>> Of course the date a page was last modified doesn't directly
indicate
>>>> how correct/current the information is, but there's a correlation.
>>>> Knowing the date would be useful in making a judgment. It might even
>>>> help the task of identifying and cleaning up obsolete pages.
>>>>
>>>> Easy to do?
>>>>
>>>> -Bob
>>>>
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Users mailing list
>>>> Users(a)ovirt.org
>>>> http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
>>>
>>
>>
>> --
>> Sandro Bonazzola
>> Better technology. Faster innovation. Powered by community collaboration.
>> See how it works at redhat.com
>> _______________________________________________
>> Users mailing list
>> Users(a)ovirt.org
>> http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users
>>
--
Sandro Bonazzola
Better technology. Faster innovation. Powered by community collaboration.
See how it works at redhat.com
3903
days inactive
3907
days old
13 comments
6 participants
participants (6)
-
Bob Doolittle -
Brian Proffitt -
Dave Neary -
Doron Fediuck -
Sandro Bonazzola -
Yedidyah Bar David