1:48 p.m.
I'm having an odd issue that i find hard to believe could be a bug, and
not some kind of user error, but im at a loss for where else to look.
when booting a linux ISO with QXL SPICE graphics, the boot hangs as soon
as kernel modesetting kicks in. Tried with latest debian, fedora, and
centos. Sometimes it randomly works, but most often it does not. QXL /
VGA VNC work fine. However if i wait a few minutes after starting the VM
for the graphics to start, then there are no issues and i can install as
usual.
So after install, i reboot, hangs on reboot right after graphics switch
back to text mode with QXL SPICE, not with VNC. So i force power off,
reboot, and wait a while for it to boot. If i did text only install,
when i open a spice console it will hang after typing a few characters.
If i did a graphical install then as long as i waited long enough for X
to start, then it works perfectly fine.
I tried to capture some logs, but since the whole guest OS hangs it's
rather hard to pull off. I did see an occasional error about the mouse
driver, so that's really all i have to go on.
As for the spice client, im using virt-viewer on windows 10 x64, tried
various versions of virt-viewer just to be sure, no change. I also have
a large amount on windows guests with QXL SPICE. These all work with no
issue. Having guest agent installed in the linux guest seems to make no
difference.
There are no out of the ordinary logs on the VDSM hosts, but i can
provide anything you may need. It's not specific to any one host, i have
10 VM hosts in the cluster, they all do. They are westmere boxes if that
makes a difference.
Any ideas on how i should approach this? VNC works well enough for text
only linux guest, but not being able to reboot my GUI linux guests
without also closing my spice connection is a small pain.
as far as ovirt versions im on the latest, this is a rather fresh
install. just set it up a few days ago, but i've been a long time ovirt
user. I am using a squid spice proxy if that makes a difference.
4:25 a.m.
On 2018-11-25 14:48, Alex McWhirter wrote:
I'm having an odd issue that i find hard to believe could be a
bug,
and not some kind of user error, but im at a loss for where else to
look.
when booting a linux ISO with QXL SPICE graphics, the boot hangs as
soon as kernel modesetting kicks in. Tried with latest debian, fedora,
and centos. Sometimes it randomly works, but most often it does not.
QXL / VGA VNC work fine. However if i wait a few minutes after
starting the VM for the graphics to start, then there are no issues
and i can install as usual.
So after install, i reboot, hangs on reboot right after graphics
switch back to text mode with QXL SPICE, not with VNC. So i force
power off, reboot, and wait a while for it to boot. If i did text only
install, when i open a spice console it will hang after typing a few
characters. If i did a graphical install then as long as i waited long
enough for X to start, then it works perfectly fine.
I tried to capture some logs, but since the whole guest OS hangs it's
rather hard to pull off. I did see an occasional error about the mouse
driver, so that's really all i have to go on.
As for the spice client, im using virt-viewer on windows 10 x64, tried
various versions of virt-viewer just to be sure, no change. I also
have a large amount on windows guests with QXL SPICE. These all work
with no issue. Having guest agent installed in the linux guest seems
to make no difference.
There are no out of the ordinary logs on the VDSM hosts, but i can
provide anything you may need. It's not specific to any one host, i
have 10 VM hosts in the cluster, they all do. They are westmere boxes
if that makes a difference.
Any ideas on how i should approach this? VNC works well enough for
text only linux guest, but not being able to reboot my GUI linux
guests without also closing my spice connection is a small pain.
as far as ovirt versions im on the latest, this is a rather fresh
install. just set it up a few days ago, but i've been a long time
ovirt user. I am using a squid spice proxy if that makes a difference.
_______________________________________________
Users mailing list -- users(a)ovirt.org
To unsubscribe send an email to users-leave(a)ovirt.org
Privacy Statement: https://www.ovirt.org/site/privacy-policy/
oVirt Code of Conduct:
https://www.ovirt.org/community/about/community-guidelines/
List Archives:
https://lists.ovirt.org/archives/list/users@ovirt.org/message/CJWU35TTEUC...
I managed to extract a log file from a debian guest.
https://pastebin.com/wNu69Edn
4:57 a.m.
Hi,
On Sun, Nov 25, 2018 at 02:48:13PM -0500, Alex McWhirter wrote:
I'm having an odd issue that i find hard to believe could be a
bug, and not some kind of user error, but im at a loss for
where else to look.
Looks like a bug or bad configuration between host/guest. Let's
see.
when booting a linux ISO with QXL SPICE graphics, the boot
hangs as soon as kernel modesetting kicks in. Tried with latest
debian, fedora, and centos. Sometimes it randomly works, but
most often it does not. QXL / VGA VNC work fine. However if i
wait a few minutes after starting the VM for the graphics to
start, then there are no issues and i can install as usual.
So after install, i reboot, hangs on reboot right after
graphics switch back to text mode with QXL SPICE, not with VNC.
So i force power off, reboot, and wait a while for it to boot.
If i did text only install, when i open a spice console it will
hang after typing a few characters. If i did a graphical
install then as long as i waited long enough for X to start,
then it works perfectly fine.
From the logs of second email:
| [ 3.201725] [drm] Initialized qxl 0.1.0 20120117 for 0000:00:02.0 on minor 0
Quite old qxl? Would it be possible to update it? 0.1.5 was
released in 2016-12-19 [0], that's almost 5 years of bugfixing,
etc.
https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/xorg/driver/xf86-video-qxl/tags/xf86-video...
I tried to capture some logs, but since the whole guest OS
hangs it's rather hard to pull off. I did see an occasional
error about the mouse driver, so that's really all i have to go
on.
As for the spice client, im using virt-viewer on windows 10
x64, tried various versions of virt-viewer just to be sure, no
change. I also have a large amount on windows guests with QXL
SPICE. These all work with no issue. Having guest agent
installed in the linux guest seems to make no difference.
There are no out of the ordinary logs on the VDSM hosts, but i
can provide anything you may need. It's not specific to any one
host, i have 10 VM hosts in the cluster, they all do. They are
westmere boxes if that makes a difference.
Any ideas on how i should approach this? VNC works well enough
for text only linux guest, but not being able to reboot my GUI
linux guests without also closing my spice connection is a
small pain.
Maybe just updating the qxl would solve the issue but which
configuration you have set in regards to memory for qxl?
I see in the logs
| [ 3.163127] [drm] qxl: 16M of VRAM memory size
| [ 3.163127] [drm] qxl: 63M of IO pages memory ready (VRAM domain)
| [ 3.163128] [drm] qxl: 32M of Surface memory size
Not sure if driver is using UMS (old) or KMS mode on Debian...
https://www.spice-space.org/multiple-monitors.html
as far as ovirt versions im on the latest, this is a rather
fresh install. just set it up a few days ago, but i've been a
long time ovirt user. I am using a squid spice proxy if that
makes a difference.
Cheers,
Victor
1969
days inactive
1977
days old
2 comments
2 participants
participants (2)
-
Alex McWhirter -
Victor Toso