[ovirt-users] ovirt and glusterfs setup

[George Skorup]

Bill,

I have done exactly what you're looking to do. I was trying to mimic 
vSAN as well. They had VSA for a while which was acceptable licensing 
costs, but that was replaced with vSAN which is ridiculously expensive 
for an extra-small business.

I have a four node cluster with 1TB of storage each. Gluster is 
configured with replica 4. So basically I have 1TB of usable storage, 
which is fine for my needs. VM migration, Gluster replication, hosted 
engine and all that works fine. Performance is generally fine, even with 
only dual LACP bonded 1GbE NICs in each node. I can do what I want with 
networking to fit our NOC and office network environment.

I have been playing with this for about three weeks. Over the weekend, I 
had a handful of VMs running, including the hosted engine. They were 
pretty much sitting idle doing nothing. I came in Monday and found 
everything offline. No power outages, network/switch didn't fail or 
reboot, none of the hardware reset. What I found happened was that 
glusterd went nuts on two of the nodes (I have no idea why). Gluster was 
spitting out logs like crazy, /var filled up, then RAM and swap was 
depleted. Two gluster processes/hosts offline out of the four meant 
quorum broke, everything came to a halt. I was unable to recover the 
gluster logs since they had to be deleted to free up space in /var.

I was able to get everything fixed and back online in about 2-1/2 hours. 
So this is impossible to put into production. Storage is the weakest 
link and mostly likely to fail, which in this case it did.

I do not recommend this configuration at all. A dedicated machine for 
the engine, dedicated hypervisors and dedicated storage nodes or a SAN 
is needed for anything beyond experimentation.

I have zero knowledge of VMWare's vSAN, other than basic concepts, so I 
cannot say the results would be similar.


On 2/18/2015 5:32 AM, Bill Dossett wrote:
>
> Hi,
>
> I’m in at the deep end…
>
> Looking for some advice on if this is possible – and what version I 
> should try I with if so.
>
> We are a heavily VMware oriented company… but I am trying to get 
> RHEV/oVirt in the door.  Honestly I would prefer oVirt, but if they 
> insist on enterprise support I go to Redhat.
>
> So I have had a play with VMware VSAN and know how it works.  I am 
> trying to more or less replicate this setup using open source.
>
> So VSAN uses 3 or more ESXi nodes, with local harddisks as the storage 
> medium as a virtual SAN.  The SAN performance is quite high as you put 
> at least 1 SSD in each node.
>
> What is nice is you don’t have the NAS element here.  VMs are on the 
> local storage, which is partially SSD, so performance is quite good.
>
> I went to a Redhat presentation on Redhat storage and GlusterFS and 
> basically this acts as a big software defined NAS which does some 
> pretty cool things, but that’s not exactly what I need.
>
> I would like to build oVirt on top of CentOS Oss… that have local 
> storage in them that is distributed and redundant in the event of a 
> node failure.
>
> And I probably need to try and build this in a lab under Fusion on my 
> Mac Book pro to begin with anyway (that bit I’m farily confident with) 
> and if I get that working can probably get some older kit to try it 
> out for real as a PoC to few people.
>
> So, I’ve set up oVirt before that should be ok, I haven’t setup 
> Gluster is there any documents that would help me down this road and 
> make sure I start out using the best version.
>
> Any advice or pointers would be gratefully received.
>
> Thanks
>
> *Bill Dossett*
>
> Systems Architect
>
> *Tech Central – Global Engineering Services*
>
> *T* +44 (0)1923 279353
>
> *M* +44 (0)777 590 8612
>
> b <mailto:jeff.gonzalez at pb.com>ill.dossett at pb.com 
> <mailto:ill.dossett at pb.com>
>
> pitneybowes.com
>
>
> *Pitney Bowes*
>
> 6 Hercules Way | Leavesden | WD25 7GS | UK
>
>
> Learn more about Global Engineering Services 
> <http://teamsite.inside.pb.com/sites/TCPPM/GES/SitePages/Home.aspx>
>
> In Engineering?
>
> *Raise a ticket via Remedy Anywhere [HERE 
> <teamsite.inside.pb.com/sites/TCPPM/GES/Lists/Create%20Incident/newIncident.aspx>]takes 
> less than a minute*
>
> **
>
> *CloudForms User Guide available* [*HERE 
> <https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/6219441/ManageIQ%20-%20User%20Manual%20PB%20v5.pdf>*]
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Users mailing list
> Users at ovirt.org
> http://lists.ovirt.org/mailman/listinfo/users

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.ovirt.org/pipermail/users/attachments/20150218/bed1b225/attachment-0001.html>